Forwarded this by a colleague? Subscribe free here.
Good morning, {{first_name|school marketer}}. Before you take next year's ad numbers to the board, check what they're actually counting.
Prologue
Your best number might be a page view
I thought about that this week when I read Jack Taylor's write-up on YouTube ads for a charter high school in Tucson.
The campaign worked. Cost per click fell from 47 cents to 22 cents, and visits to the enrollment page grew every month. Then he opened the conversion settings. Google Ads had reported nearly 2,000 conversions in October. Every one of them was somebody viewing the enrollment page. None were inquiries.
I see this all the time. A form fill, a page view, and a click on the phone number all get lumped together as "conversions," and nobody checks which one is firing.
It matters right now. In a few weeks you'll be building next year's budget, and somebody will ask what the ads produced.
Here's a 15-minute check for this week:
Open Google Ads and go to your conversion actions.
For each one, write down what actually triggers it.
Keep only real inquiries, tour bookings, and applications as primary. Move everything else to secondary.
If you find a page view in there, you're not alone. Hit reply and tell me what you found. I read every reply.
Thanks,
Brendan
Sponsor
For MarCom Society Members
Members only

Thursday, December 3, 12:00 to 1:00 p.m. ET. Live stream in the Lunch & Learn Sessions space.
I'll build a one-page 2027 plan live in Claude: three priorities, the channels that earn their keep, a quarter-by-quarter calendar, and the one number you report to the board. You leave with the prompts, the template, and a first draft of your own plan. The prompt pack and template go in the member Library the same day.
Not a member yet? Join The MarCom Society.
Know a colleague who'd like this? Share School Marketing Insider and get the 20-Minute ChatGPT Check.
This Week's Picks
Jack Taylor, Nov 5, 2026
Real numbers from three months of YouTube ads. "Get Ahead" beat "Catch Up," the teacher video beat the testimonial, and the 17-second cut beat the 65-second one. Read section 7 twice. The "conversions" were page views.
DNI Consulting (Dana Nelson-Isaacs), Nov 10, 2026
Dana's exercise takes 15 minutes. Pull three lists: families who inquired but never visited, families who visited but never applied, and families who started an application and stalled. The longest list tells you where to look first, and I'd run it before Thanksgiving.
Elevate Marketing Strategy (Laurie Ehrlich), Nov 10, 2026
If your open house ad sends families to your homepage, you're making them dig. Laurie's case for a landing page is simple: one audience, one message, one next step. It also lets you see whether the ad worked.
Enrollment Catalyst (Rick Newberry), Oct 28, 2026
Rick's point is one I make a lot: when enrollment drops, more marketing is the first instinct and often the wrong first move. Split the problem into new students and returning students before you spend a dollar. His example says it well: enroll 40, lose 45, and you're behind before graduation.
Search Engine Land (Barry Schwartz), Nov 9, 2026
Google now shows ads under the follow-up questions in an AI Mode conversation, too. If you run Google Ads for your school, ask whoever manages them how AI Mode placements are showing up in your reports.
20 More Students (Tom Sheppard), Oct 28, 2026
McDonogh and St. Andrew's in Maryland built college partnerships that guarantee admission and merit scholarships to students who meet set criteria. McDonogh's started with one conversation on a college visit. It's a good example of adding value instead of discounting tuition, and it gives admissions a concrete story to tell.
Listen and Watch
Podcast
Independent School Moonshot Podcast (Peter Baron with Dr. Dan Love and Heather-Hope Joseph), Nov 9, 2026
The American International School of Lagos had a big jump in enrollment. They got staff, the board, and the PTO ready before the new families arrived, and their Welcome Day brought in local doctors and grocery stores. My favorite line: when lots of new people show up at once, you have to say out loud who you are.
Share School Marketing Insider
Know a colleague who'd like this? Share School Marketing Insider and I'll send you the 20-Minute ChatGPT Check. It's a quick way to see what AI tools say about your school.
Latest MarCom Society Jobs
Ways I can help
Fractional Digital Marketer Program: we run inbound marketing, Google Ads, Meta Ads, SEO, reputation management, and blogging for you. Learn more.
School Marketing The Right Way: the book I wished existed when I started marketing a school. Purchase.
SchoolMarketingCRM: marketing software for schools, including landing pages, email automation, reputation management, and appointment scheduling. Learn more.
The MarCom Society: training, support, and community for school marketing and communication professionals. Learn more.
Sponsor this newsletter: put your work in front of the school marketers who read School Marketing Insider. Learn more.

